November 17, 2026|Client Alerts
Initial Takeaways for Employers: Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, “Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program”
By Meredith Doll
On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) published a proposed rule that contemplates several significant changes to the agency’s long-standing PERM program. The proposed changes are substantial and, if adopted as currently written, will most likely be subject to protracted litigation before they can be implemented.
Whether employers will be required to adhere to any of these proposed policies is anyone’s guess; however, understanding the scope and likely impact of the proposed changes is essential for employers contemplating or pursuing employment-based permanent residence on behalf of foreign workers.
A Primer on PERM
Under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), an employer’s ability to sponsor a foreign worker for permanent residence (i.e., “green card”) is highly restricted. For employment-based immigration to be an option, the foreign worker and, by extension, their employer and the job serving as the basis for sponsorship, must all qualify for one of the available five employment-based (EB) immigrant preference categories.[1]
However, the reality is that most employers are only able to take advantage of two EB preference categories: the second preference (EB-2) category, for sponsored workers with an advanced degree or exceptional ability; and the third preference (EB-3) category, which includes workers with a bachelor’s degree, skilled workers with at least two years of experience, and other workers.
Of course, employers cannot simply file an immigrant sponsorship petition with USCIS to have a foreign worker classified in the EB-2 or EB-3 categories.[2] The INA prohibits foreign workers from obtaining green cards through the EB-2 or EB-3 categories unless the Department of Labor has certified (i) that no able, willing, qualified U.S. workers are available to fill the position offered to the foreign worker, and (ii) that the wages and working conditions of similarly situated U.S. workers will not be adversely affected by the sponsorship of the foreign worker. A permanent labor certification is the document issued by the DOL certifying that the sponsoring employer has met those requirements.
PERM, on the other hand, is the regulatory program currently used by the DOL to evaluate whether the proposed employment-based sponsorship meets the two applicable criteria and, if so, to issue a corresponding permanent labor certification. Under the PERM program, an employer is required to obtain a prevailing wage determination, which sets the minimum wage that the employer can offer for the position; to post a regulatory notice at the proposed worksite; and to conduct a limited set of recruitment steps to advertise the position in an attempt to identify whether any able, willing, and qualified U.S. workers are available to fill the position.
If the employer does not identify any able, willing, qualified, and available U.S. workers after completing the required pre-filing activities, then it may apply for permanent labor certification (Form ETA-9089) to the DOL for processing. And if the employer does identify a potentially qualified U.S. worker? It is simply not eligible to apply for permanent labor certification on behalf of the foreign worker it wants to sponsor. The employer certainly isn’t required to hire any potentially qualified U.S. worker it identifies; and the employer remains able to employ the foreign worker in a temporary (nonimmigrant) work-authorized status.
The Proposed Changes
The scope of the changes proposed by the DOL is massive. However, not all the proposed changes will negatively impact employers if implemented. Some neutral-to-positive proposals include:
- Elimination of the required Sunday newspaper print advertisements, a change that, if implemented, would reduce the cost of recruitment to employers by eliminating what is frequently the costliest recruitment step.
- Explicit adoption of electronic posting of the Notice of Filing (NOF) as an alternative to physical notice postings, which would greatly streamline NOF posting for many employers.
- Specific prevailing wage and recruitment standards for remote, roving, and telework (hybrid) job opportunities, a long-awaited update to Field Memorandum No. 48-94 (the “Farmer” memo), which has been the controlling policy on this issue since 1994.
Of course, there are many more proposed changes that radically increase the burden on employers of undertaking the PERM process on behalf of a foreign worker:
- Elimination of Schedule A: The proposed rule would eliminate Schedule A entirely, forcing employers to undertake the full PERM recruitment process for physical therapists, professional nurses, and individuals with exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or performing arts who don’t otherwise qualify for a national interest waiver. Under the current PERM rule, employers are only required to obtain a prevailing wage determination and complete the notice posting requirement before proceeding to file the immigrant sponsorship petition on behalf of individuals who fall into one of the Schedule A professions; employers are not required to conduct pre-filing recruitment or file Form ETA-9089 with the DOL for Schedule A workers. Healthcare systems, medical providers, institutes of higher education and research organizations will likely be most affected by this change, if it is ultimately adopted.
- Expanded Layoff Bar: The proposed rule would bar an employer from filing a PERM application if it has laid off any similarly situated U.S. worker within the preceding two years, unless the employer offers, and the laid-off worker refuses, the PERM job opportunity. Under the current rule, employers must only consider layoffs conducted within the six months preceding filing; and are only required to notify laid-off worker(s) of the job opportunity and give them an opportunity to apply. Furthermore, the proposed rule would impose an affirmative obligation to notify the DOL of any such layoffs occurring after the filing of the PERM application, until the corresponding Form I-140 petition is approved by USCIS.
- Expanded Duration of Required Notice and Recruitment: The proposed rule would drastically increase the duration of required notice posting and recruitment activities—
- The State Workforce Agency (SWA) job order andPERM job advertisements would be required to remain active for 90 days minimum. The current rule requires 30 days for the SWA job order and no minimum duration for the job advertisements.
- The NOF would be required to be posted within the 10 business days preceding the filing of the ETA-9089 and to remain active until the corresponding I-140 is approved by USCIS—easily one year or longer. The current rule requires the NOF to be posted for 10 business days, no more than 180 days and no less than 30 days prior to the filing of the ETA-9089.
- Expanded Mandatory Recruitment Steps: The proposed rule fully embraces electronic recruitment, requiring mandatory PERM job advertisements to be posted on the employer’s website, at least one additional job search website and on any social media platforms normally used by the employer to advertise job openings (like LinkedIn). It also appears to require employers to advertise the position at least one job fair, on-campus recruiting event, or with a campus placement office at a college, university or trade school, regardless of whether the employer normally uses such methods to recruit.
- Shortened Recruitment Validity: The proposed rule would require recruitment to be completed between 30 to 60 calendar days preceding the filing of Form ETA-9089. The proposed rule is not clear regarding how this requirement comports with the proposed requirement that job advertisements remain active for at least 90 days.
- Submission of Recruitment Documentation with ETA-9089: Rather surprisingly, the proposed rule would require employers to submit their completed Recruitment Report, audit documentation of all required postings, and the application and screening materials for every single applicant, with Form ETA-9089. When it enacted the current PERM rule, the DOL explicitly chose not to require employers to submit these materials with each filing, implementing instead a random audit process to streamline the adjudications process and reduce the demands on its Certifying Officers. This proposed change will almost certainly push PERM application processing times well beyond the current 10-12 months if adopted.
However, all this pales in comparison to the most significant change proposed by the DOL—the imposition of post-filing and post-certification compliance obligations on sponsoring employers.
Proposed Post-Filing and Post-Certification Requirements
The current PERM regulation requires the sponsoring employer to satisfy certain notice and recruitment requirements as a prerequisite to filing an application for permanent labor certification with the DOL. The proposed rule raises the compliance stakes considerably:
- Notice of Filing Duration: The proposed rule contemplates requiring employers to post the NOF within the ten days preceding the filing of Form ETA-9089 and to leave it posted until the corresponding Form I-140 is approved. For reference, the Form I-140 is the immigrant sponsorship petition that the employer files with USCIS afterthe DOL certifies the Form ETA-9089. Considering currently posted processing times, that means an employer would be expected to maintain the NOF posting for up to 16 months[3]–compared to 10 business days under the current rule.
- Required Layoff Notifications: As noted in the previous section, the proposed rule contemplates barring employers from filing a PERM application if they have laid off a similarly situated U.S. worker within the preceding two years. The proposed provision would require employers:
- To offer the job opportunity to any similarly situated U.S. worker laid off during the preceding two years and only proceed with filing the PERM application if the employer documents that the laid-off worker(s) refused the offer or was disqualified for lawful, job-related reasons.
- To notify the DOL within five days of laying off a similarly situated U.S. worker, if the layoff occurs any time after the filing of the PERM application until the approval of the corresponding I-140 by USCIS. If the layoff occurs while the I-140 petition is pending, the proposed regulation would also require employers to notify USCIS of the layoff.
- To not place a sponsored worker at a third-party worksite, if there are “indicia of an employment relationship” between the third party and the sponsored worker, and the third party has laid off similarly situated U.S. workers during the two years preceding the filing of the PERM application or lays off such a worker after the filing of the PERM application until the corresponding I-140 petition is approved by USCIS.
- Required Recruitment Report Updates: As noted in the previous section, the proposed rule would require employers to submit their Recruitment Reports together with Form ETA-9089. The proposed rule would also require the employer to update its Recruitment Report to reflect any relevant layoff(s) and the steps undertaken by the employer to offer the position to laid off, similarly situated U.S. workers. However, the proposed rule would only require the employer to submit the updated Recruitment Report to DOL upon request.
Key Issues for Employers to Consider
Whether or not this proposed rule is ultimately implemented, it’s clear that employer PERM compliance is a priority target for enforcement. With that in mind, here are a few action items that employers should consider undertaking while the notice-and-comment process plays out:
- Integrate Immigration into Workforce Planning – Conducting a layoff as an employer with sponsored nonimmigrant workers creates significant risk of a government enforcement action. Employers must document and be prepared to defend layoff decisions, especially if nonimmigrant workers are retained over U.S. workers.
- Audit your PERM Audit Files – The current regulations require employers to maintain PERM audit materials for five years after the filing of the ETA-9089. Employers should ensure that PERM audit files are complete without retaining unnecessary documentation.
- Formalize your Recruitment Practices – The DOL and DOJ have both undertaken enforcement actions against employers for alleged citizenship status discrimination during the PERM recruitment process. Employers that adopt and implement formal recruitment practices should consider any differences between recruitment for PERM and non-PERM roles.
- Establish and Implement Benchmarks – In this period of heightened enforcement, having established standards for job duties, requirements, and wages, and documented justifications for those standards, is essential to defending government enforcement actions alleging unlawful discrimination against U.S. workers.
[1] The EB-1 category is reserved for “priority workers” (individuals with extraordinary ability, outstanding professors and researchers, and multinational executives and managers); EB-4 is reserved for “special immigrants,” primarily religious workers; and EB-5 is reserved for immigrant investors participating in the EB-5 program.
[2] Unless, of course, that foreign worker qualifies for a National Interest Waiver (NIW) of the labor certification requirement; but filing such an NIW petition carries its own burdens and risks.
[3] As of November 17, 2026, the DOL is posting PERM processing times of 300-360 days (https://flag.dol.gov/processingtimes); and USCIS is posting Form I-140 processing times of 3 months and 4 months, for EB-2 and EB-3 categories respectively (https://egov.uscis.gov/processing-times).
This communication is not intended to create or constitute, nor does it create or constitute, an attorney-client or any other legal relationship. No statement in this communication constitutes legal advice nor should any communication herein be construed, relied upon, or interpreted as legal advice. This communication is for general information purposes only regarding recent legal developments of interest, and is not a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader should act or refrain from acting on the basis of any information included herein without seeking appropriate legal advice on the particular facts and circumstances affecting that reader. For more information, visit www.buchalter.com.